Seems like all I’m writing about these days is people who have died.
They say things happen in threes, and noteworthy deaths – at least noteworthy to me – lately have included former Montana football player Montana Bockman, the versatile Frank McElwain, and most recently, former Great Falls High and University of Montana football coach Gene Carlson.
Carlson joined Jack Swarthout’s staff as an assistant before taking over the head job when Jack called it quits after the 1975 season. A recent Missoulian sports story by Fritz Neighbor recounted that – during his four-year tenure – Carlson’s teams won just 16 of 41 games, but had a lot of talented players.
One of Carlson’s assistants, current Big Sky High School coach Gary Ekegren, had some nice and appropriate things to say about Carlson and the way he approached trying to build a program at UM when football had gone into a bit of a slump after Swarthout’s banner years of 1969 and 1970.
I was radio voice of the Grizzlies back then, and recall a rather peculiar incident with Carlson – peculiar because of his usually calm demeanor and approach to all things football.
One of the unfortunate things about Gene’s first year as head coach was a quarterback controversy. Grizzly fans these days know all about quarterback controversies. At some level, they’re almost an annual event.
This one involved Mike Roban, a former Great Falls High player under Carlson who transferred to UM after an unsuccessful attempt to attend, and play football for, a military academy.
Roban was at Montana for two seasons, and he got off to a rocky start in his first one, also Gene’s first as head coach.
Carlson certainly had first-hand knowledge of Roban’s talents. A talented thrower and runner, Roban didn’t fare too badly on the football field at the academy, but apparently couldn’t handle the discipline.
Mike was more than a little cocky. Because of that, many of those whose teams played against him in high school didn’t much care for him, and many of those same folks probably weren’t willing to give him the benefit of the doubt when he wound up at UM.
Montana also had a junior college transfer quarterback named Mike Magner in 1976 and, when he got playing time, he seemed to be outplaying Roban, who was struggling.
Part way through the season my color commentator, Ken Staninger, and I showed up at Carlson’s office to record our weekly pregame show. The quarterback subject came up, not because I wanted it to, but because it had to.
I asked Carlson who would start at quarterback in the upcoming game. The room temperature cooled noticeably as Carlson responded, “Who would you start?” Still relatively new to the profession, I made a mistake.
Rather than turning off the recorder and discussing things with Carlson, I chose to answer, “I guess if it was up to me, based on what I’ve seen so far this season, I’d probably go with Magner.”
I don’t recall much of the rest of the interview, such as it was. But I vividly remember what happened at the end.
Carlson snapped, “Don’t ever ask me a question like that again!” I replied, “That’s the question that every Grizzly fan wants the answer to. I had to ask it.”
At this point Staninger jumped in with a few pointed comments of his own in my support, and then we left.
I don’t even remember who started the next game at quarterback for the Grizzlies. All I remember is that the next time Staninger and I showed up, it was as though the incident had never happened.
Carlson was back to his old self, and things went smoothly from then on out.
I guess it just shows that the pressure of coaching college football can get to anyone. But Carlson proved that the important thing is how you respond to that pressure.
I thought he bounced back in exceptional fashion. And that’s one of the reasons that, when it became apparent he was about to lose his job as UM’s head coach, I went to the UM president’s office to intercede on his behalf.
It didn’t work, but I felt it was something that needed to be done. UM had a lot of issues with its athletic program at the time, most of them tied to inadequate funding. A lot of us felt that it wouldn’t matter who the head coach was if he wasn’t given more tools with which to work.
UM went through another coaching staff before one of the issues was solved with the construction of Washington-Grizzly Stadium. The funding issue slowly began to resolve itself as more fans came out to watch Don Read’s wide-open offense.
It’s anybody’s guess how much the offense would have mattered had the Grizzlies kept playing at Dornblaser Stadium.
Anyway, I’ll always have a lot of respect for Gene Carlson. He was a good man and a good football coach who was more the victim of circumstances than of any shortcomings he may have had.
Rest in peace, Gene. And all the best to your family.
- Bill Schwanke